Comparing Measures of Line Jaggedness

This Demonstration compares three statistical measures of line jaggedness visually and numerically. It creates and plots rugged curves with the Mandelbrot–Weierstrass function, , of a chosen fractal dimension , starting point, range, and resolution, and curve-fits the data with a third- or fourth-degree polynomial. The fitted ("smoothed") curve is superimposed on the generated curve with the residuals plotted below. The residuals' standard deviation, , and two additional jaggedness indices, and , having a range from 0 (perfectly smooth) to 1, are calculated and their values displayed. Also included is a plot showing these two indices' dependence on for a chosen range factor .


  • [Snapshot]
  • [Snapshot]
  • [Snapshot]


Snapshot 1: smooth line
Snapshot 2: moderately jagged line at high resolution
Snapshot 3: highly jagged line at high resolution
Jagged compressive force-displacement curves are the hallmark of brittle puffed cereals and snacks and other solid foams. It has been shown that these curves' degree of jaggedness is not only a measure of brittleness [1] but also of the perceived "crunchiness" or "crispness" [2]. This Demonstration generates jagged lines using the Mandelbrot–Weierstrass function, , having a chosen fractal dimension , number of terms , phase angle , frequency multiplier , and scale factor , all entered with sliders. You can also choose with sliders the number of generated points and the starting point on the curve.
The program curve-fits the generated data with a third- or fourth-degree polynomial model, selected with a setter bar, and superimposes the fitted curve on the generated data. The program also calculates the residuals and displays them separately in the plot below. It then provides numerical and visual comparison of three statistical indices of line jaggedness [3], namely, the standard deviation of the residuals after curve fitting with the polynomial model , , and , where is a range factor chosen with a slider. The dependence of and on for the chosen is displayed in the bottom plot, with the actual value of and at shown as a moving red or blue dot, respectively. Unlike , which is unbounded, and the fractal dimension , which has a theoretical range from 1 to 2, both and have a range from 0 (perfectly smooth, ) to 1 ().
The Demonstration lets you examine how the statistical jaggedness parameters (, , and ) are affected by the curve's inherent jaggedness, as expressed by its fractal dimension, and the resolution, which can be altered by adjusting other parameters (primarily and ).
Although the indices were originally proposed for the characterization of the compressive force-displacement curves of brittle foods, they could also be used for jagged line signatures that might be encountered in other fields.
[1] M. G. Corradini and M. Peleg, "Solid Food Foams," Properties of Food Cellular Solids and Food Composites (J. M. Aguillera and P. Lillford, eds.), New York: Springer, 2007 pp. 169–202.
[2] T. Suwonsichon and M. Peleg, "Instrumental and Sensory Detection of Simultaneous Brittleness Loss and Moisture Toughening in Three Puffed Cereal Products," Journal of Texture Studies, 29(3), 1998 pp. 255–274.
[3] M. Peleg, "Line Jaggedness Measures and Their Applications in Textural Evaluation of Foods," Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 37, 1997 pp. 491–518.
    • Share:

Embed Interactive Demonstration New!

Just copy and paste this snippet of JavaScript code into your website or blog to put the live Demonstration on your site. More details »

Files require Wolfram CDF Player or Mathematica.