Snapshot 1: The estimated size of population can be considerably smaller than the true size if the largest number in the sample happens to be relatively small, as is the case here. Recall that the estimator is

, where

is the largest number in the sample. Thus, if

is small, the estimate is small, too. The smallest value of

is

(this is the case when we happen to get the sample 1, 2, …,

); in this case the estimate of

is

.

Snapshot 2: The estimated size of population can also be somewhat larger than the true size if

happens to be near to the true size of population. However, note that the estimate is always at most

. For example, if

and

, the estimate is at most 109.

Snapshot 3: Here is the frequency distribution of the percent estimation error, when

is a random integer between 100 and 1000 and the sampling percentage is 1. The frequencies are calculated for the error intervals …,

,

,

,

, …; the frequencies come from

simulations for each sampling percentage 1, 2, …, 100. Note the smooth behavior on the left side of the distribution, the nonsmooth behavior on the right side, the very uncommon occurrence of an estimation error greater than 50%, and the peak in between 8.5% and 9.5%. In a vast majority of cases, the percent error is between -50% and 50%.

Snapshot 4: Here the sampling percentage is 2, and now the vast majority of percent estimation errors is between -30% and 30% and the peak is at between 4.5% and 5.5%.

Snapshot 5: Now the sampling percentage is 3. Most percent estimation errors are between -24% and 24% and the peak is between 2.5% and 3.5%.

Snapshot 6: When the sampling percentage is 14, the peak of the distribution is, for the first time, at the origin, that is, between 0.5% and 0.5%.

The method can also be used to estimate, for example, the number of taxicabs or tanks. According to [1], it can be shown that the given estimator,

, is the uniformly minimum variance unbiased estimator of

. Unbiasedness means that the expectation of the estimator is

. The Demonstration is based on problem 12 in [2].

[1] R. W. Johnson, "Estimating the Size of a Population,"

*Teaching Statistics*,

**16**(2), 1994 pp. 50–52.

[2] P. J. Nahin,

*Digital Dice: Computational Solutions to Practical Probability Problems*, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2008.