11403

Risk Guesstimation from Factor Ranges

In "risk guesstimation", the magnitudes of the guessed factors are multiplied to find an estimate. In this Demonstration, each factor's guessed value is the geometric mean of the lower and upper limits of its probable range. The result is compared with the analytically calculated value based on the assumption of uniform probability distribution within each factor's range. The analytical result is the mode of the displayed lognormal distribution expected from the central limit theorem.

SNAPSHOTS

  • [Snapshot]
  • [Snapshot]
  • [Snapshot]

DETAILS

Snapshot 1: guesstimation of the number of daily food poisoning episodes in a hypothetical large city
Snapshot 2: guesstimation of the number of food poisoning episodes at a hypothetical wedding from a contaminated salad
Snapshot 3: guesstimation of the number of spoiled hypothetical food product units after being on the market for several years
A simple "back-of-the-envelope" calculation method also known as a "Fermi problem" [1] or "guesstimation" [2] is based on multiplying the estimated or guessed values of several factors. The method frequently works because if the factor guesses are "reasonable", it is unlikely that all or even most of them will differ considerably from the correct values. Thus, due to mutual compensation, their product would be close to the actual value. The method can be applied to estimate the number of food poisoning victims of spoiled food product units , using the formula , where is the number of affected persons (e.g. a restaurant's guests) or the number of food items not yet consumed, and the are the chain of probabilities (e.g. of a customer eating the infected dish , of consuming a large enough quantity of it , of being in poor health , etc.).
In some cases, coming up with reasonable guesses for and the can be difficult, and different experts might choose differently. It would be much easier, however, to identify these factors' probable ranges, such as and , and , and , etc. and run Monte Carlo simulations to extract the most probable value of , which can also be calculated analytically [3]. It can be and has been shown that when the factors are multiplicative, the distribution of the generated 's is approximately lognormal, as expected from the central limit theorem (CLT) [3]. The mode of this distribution is the best estimate of , and it was found to be in agreement with the value calculated analytically, based on the assumption that the factors have uniform distribution within their respective ranges [3].
In this Demonstration we have replaced the Monte Carlo simulations in the original version of the expanded Fermi solution with single parameter values calculated as the geometric mean of their upper and lower limits [2], that is, .
Use the sliders to enter the parameters' minimum and maximum values. The calculated value is displayed together with the value calculated analytically with the formulas written by Horowitz [3]. Also shown is the theoretical lognormal distribution of generated with the analytically derived logarithmic mean and standard deviation.
Notice that the guesstimation method based on the parameters' geometric means becomes totally impractical whenever any of the entered values of the lower limits is zero, rendering a zero guesstimate regardless of the other factors' magnitudes. The same is true whenever any of the entered values of the lower limits is close to zero relative to their corresponding upper limit, in which case the geometric mean would again be unreasonably small.
References
[1] H. C. von Baeyer, The Fermi Solution: Reflections on the Meaning of Physics, London: Penguin, 1993.
[2] L. Weinstein and J. A. Adam, Guesstimation: Solving the World's Problems on the Back of a Cocktail Napkin, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2008.
[3] M. Peleg, M. D. Normand, J. Horowitz, and M. G. Corradini, "An Expanded Fermi Solution for Microbial Risk Assessment," International Journal of Food Microbiology, 113(1), 2007 pp. 92–101. doi:10.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2006.07.020.
    • Share:

Embed Interactive Demonstration New!

Just copy and paste this snippet of JavaScript code into your website or blog to put the live Demonstration on your site. More details »

Files require Wolfram CDF Player or Mathematica.









 
RELATED RESOURCES
Mathematica »
The #1 tool for creating Demonstrations
and anything technical.
Wolfram|Alpha »
Explore anything with the first
computational knowledge engine.
MathWorld »
The web's most extensive
mathematics resource.
Course Assistant Apps »
An app for every course—
right in the palm of your hand.
Wolfram Blog »
Read our views on math,
science, and technology.
Computable Document Format »
The format that makes Demonstrations
(and any information) easy to share and
interact with.
STEM Initiative »
Programs & resources for
educators, schools & students.
Computerbasedmath.org »
Join the initiative for modernizing
math education.
Step-by-Step Solutions »
Walk through homework problems one step at a time, with hints to help along the way.
Wolfram Problem Generator »
Unlimited random practice problems and answers with built-in step-by-step solutions. Practice online or make a printable study sheet.
Wolfram Language »
Knowledge-based programming for everyone.
Powered by Wolfram Mathematica © 2017 Wolfram Demonstrations Project & Contributors  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy  |  RSS Give us your feedback
Note: To run this Demonstration you need Mathematica 7+ or the free Mathematica Player 7EX
Download or upgrade to Mathematica Player 7EX
I already have Mathematica Player or Mathematica 7+