This Demonstration studies the functions of the form , where and are real numbers and , , are the colormatching functions of the CIE 1931 Standard Colorimetric Observer. The main reason for being interested in these functions is that among them there are the spectral responses of electronic cameras that "see colors just like normal humans," meaning that two spectral distributions of radiant energy are indistinguishable for the camera if and only if they are indistinguishable for a normal human observer. Since spectral responses of photo detectors are always positive, the functions of interest are the positive ones. Since the , , are positive by definition, trivially positive linear combinations result if , , and are positive. There are, however, also cases where one of these three coefficients is negative. These were determined in [1]. This Demonstration lets you inspect all relevant linear combinations by placing the point in the display area with the same coordinate system as the CIE chromaticity diagram. The curve associated with this point is displayed as a colored curve. The display area is structured by a bundle of lines, each belonging to the spectral color in which it is drawn. For any visible wavelength , the corresponding line is drawn such that to on this line there belongs a linear combination of colormatching functions that vanishes at . There is a convex region that is free of these colored lines. The points of this region belong to positive functions and the points on the boundary correspond to functions that touch their axis. The boundary of the linefree area shows a striking similarity to the spectral locus, which is displayed as a colored line. You can use a second point (named instead of ) to compare the two situations. Control labels and graphics are explained in tooltips that appear when you mouse over them.
Snapshot 1: Bestconcentrated red response (colored) and for comparison (gray). The colored curve has a much smaller side lobe. Snapshot 2: Bestconcentrated red response (colored) and the bestconcentrated red response without a side lobe (gray). The redsensitive cones in the human eye have a spectral response similar to the gray curve. Snapshot 3: Bestconcentrated green response (colored) and for comparison (gray). Snapshot 4: Bestconcentrated blue response (colored) and for comparison (gray). Since the two response curves differ only very little, only a small portion of the full display area is shown. Among the positive functions of the form , there are members that show a stronger concentration toward a dominant wavelength than can be seen in the original functions , , . Surprisingly, there is a welldefined triplet of bestconcentrated functions. Their points all belong to the boundary of the convex linefree area and are placed such that they form a triangle of maximal area. The particular geometry of the linefree area makes it easy to find these points: Two points are given as the two edges of the area and the third point is determined by having maximum distance from the connecting line between the two edges. If one poses the condition that each curve should have a single maximum, one has to choose the third point differently and finds that the area is 71% of the maximum area. Taking into account shot noise in the color channels of electronic cameras, one arrives at the conclusion that the number of distinguishable signal triplets is proportional to the triangle area [2]. 1. M. L. Pearson and J. A. C. Yule, "Transformations of Color Mixture Functions without Negative Portions," Journal of Color & Appearance, II(I), 1973. 2. U. Mutze, General Properties of Metamerism Preserving Color Imaging Systems, Kodak Technical Report, Hybrid Imaging Research Laboratories Europe, Accession No. 278861D 02/16/1993, unpublished.
