Wolfram Demonstrations Project

Accounting for the anomaly in the perihelion precession of Mercury provided early support for Einstein's General Theory of Relativity [1]. Very conveniently, accurate astronomical data was already available. Schwarzschild's solution to Einstein's gravitational field equations can be approximated by Newtonian gravity perturbed by a short-range term of magnitude proportional to the Schwarzschild radius

, where

is the universal gravitational constant,

is the attracting mass (the Sun) and

is the speed of light [2, 3].

Assuming negligible gravitational radiation and using the Schwarzschild spacetime geometry, the precessing orbit of a test mass

(the planet Mercury) can be solved exactly, in terms of the Weierstrass

function [4, 5]. The same solution pertains to a star orbiting a black hole [6]. On many astronomical scales,

is a small number, so that perturbation theory is applicable. Using the methods of [7] and Approximating the Jacobian Elliptic Functions, we calculate an approximation to the exact solution as an expansion in a parameter

up to order

[8]. This Demonstration shows that in many cases the complicated Weierstrass

function is not necessary for high-precision analysis. An approximation of sufficient precision can usually be obtained in a relatively short time.

Contributed by: Brad Klee.

Slider Zoom
Gamepad Controls
Automatic Animation

In all plots, blue shows the exact solution, green shows the arbitrary-precision approximation and red shows the classical Kepler/Newton approximation.

In this computation, we set

and

. Then the effective radial potential is:

with minimum at

where we introduce the normalized parameter

restricted to the range

. Expanding the potential around the minimum gives

with

The frequency

of small oscillations is then given by

Taking the first-order term from the Big Precession Equation (see Estimating Planetary Perihelion Precession) and substituting in values for

, we obtain [8]:

This is the simplest exact form for zero-order precession. As

and

, then

and there is no precession. As

and

, then

. In terms of the effective potential, the divergence occurs as the local minimum nears the local maximum and the curve flattens out. The local max and min coincide when

. The Schwarzschild radius is at

. At the critical point,

gives the relative radius of the innermost stable circular orbit (isco), depicted as a dashed black line around the black hole in the orbit graphs. The prediction that

provides a test for all solutions: as

, the orbit should approach no closer to

than

Other authors [9-11] discuss aesthetically pleasing solutions that arise from a conspiracy of parameters, as occurs with

. It is possible to write an algorithm that operates on the approximate solution, a particular value for

and a rational number

, that returns an approximate solution for the

value, ultimately by finding the root of a polynomial equation. Acceptable values close to

can be found quickly using a linear procedure because

is a small number. For example for

and

. Doing a quick search, we obtain the following approximate "Magic Numbers":

				❘					❘
1/2	6/5	0.702	0.007	❘	1/20	2	0.252	0.009	❘	1/50	3	0.113	0.024
1/2	5/4	0.652	0.012	❘	2/20	2	0.259	0.035	❘	2/50	3	0.118	0.089
1/2	4/3	0.584	0.024	❘	3/20	2	0.269	0.074	❘	3/50	3	0.126	0.181
1/2	3/2	0.489	0.069	❘	4/20	2	0.283	0.119	❘	4/50	3	0.136	0.286

Exploring these sequences shows interesting properties of closed orbits. We see that each figure has

-fold dihedral symmetry with

crossing points.

From a mathematical perspective, it would be interesting to extend the precision measurement of

values, prove the empirical crossing formula and give a physical characterization of the crossing points using the full equations of motion, but physicists will be more interested in comparing predictions with data. Planetary precession calculations often use only the zero-order precession terms. For example, Mercury has

which implies

arcseconds per Julian century.

Substituting

, this Demonstration shows that a Kepler/Newton approximation is almost good enough to describe an isolated Mercury-Sun system on the order of one year. In more extreme gravity, the zero-order approximation fails, and higher-order energy dependence needs to be considered. This is an exciting opportunity, as humankind continues to develop incredible new experiments in black hole astronomy [2, 6].

References

[1] A. Einstein, "Erklärung der Perihelionbewegung der Merkur aus der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie." Sitzungsberichte der Königlich Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1915 pp. 831–839. (Sep 27, 2016) einsteinpapers.press.princeton.edu/vol6-doc/261. English translation: einsteinpapers.press.princeton.edu/vol6-trans/128?ajax.

[2] J. A. Wheeler, A Journey into Gravity and Spacetime, New York: W. H. Freeman and Co., 1990 pp. 168–183.

[3] R. M. Wald, General Relativity, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984 pp. 139–143.

[4] K. Weierstrass, "Zur Theorie der elliptischen Functionen," Sitzungsberichte der Königlich Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1882. (Sep 28, 2016) archive.org/stream/mathematischewer02weieuoft#page/244/mode/2up.

[5] M. Abramowitz and I. A. Stegun (eds.), Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables, New York: Dover Publications, 1965. (Sep 28, 2016) people.math.sfu.ca/~cbm/aands/page_627.htm.

[6] G. Scharf. "Schwarzschild Geodesics in Terms of Elliptic Functions and the Related Red Shift." arxiv.org/abs/1101.1207.

[7] B. Klee. "Plane Pendulum and Beyond by Phase Space Geometry." arxiv.org/abs/1605.09102.

[8] F. Frohlich. "Another Planetary Sequence" (thread). SeqFan. (Sep 11, 2016) list.seqfan.eu/pipermail/seqfan/2016-September/016731.html.

[9] P. Erdös, "Spiraling the Earth with C. G. J. Jacobi," American Journal of Physics, 68(10), 2000 pp. 888–895. doi:10.1119/1.1285882.

[10] W. G. Harter. "Classical Mechanics with a Bang!," Unit 3, p. 46. (Sep 28, 2016) www.uark.edu/ua/modphys/markup/CMwBang_Info_ 2016.html.

[11] S. Wolfram, "Black Hole Tech?," from Stephen Wolfram Blog—A Wolfram Web Resource. (Sep 28, 2016) blog.stephenwolfram.com/2016/02/black-hole-tech.

Approximating the Jacobian Elliptic Functions (Wolfram Demonstrations Project)

Estimating Planetary Perihelion Precession (Wolfram Demonstrations Project)

Brad Klee.

"Exact and Approximate Relativistic Corrections to the Orbital Precession of Mercury"
http://demonstrations.wolfram.com/ExactAndApproximateRelativisticCorrectionsToTheOrbitalPreces/
Wolfram Demonstrations Project
Published: September 29, 2016